ScienceNews states that:

Scientists had previously identified methane on Mars using Earth-based telescopes and spacecraft orbiting the Red Planet. In 2003, researchers detected a concentration as high as 45 ppb. Since then, experiments have reported much lower levels of less than 10 ppb.

This was in response to the Curiosity Rover not detecting methane on the surface of Mars, where previous Earth based studies had found it to exist.

What are the possible reasons behind this miscalculation that were done based on ground observation, and why are they mostly searching for methane?

  • $\begingroup$ This is a really good question. Added the blurb about Curiosity not detecting Methane, which is very relevant to understand the question by itself. $\endgroup$
    – PearsonArtPhoto
    Sep 24, 2013 at 14:25

1 Answer 1


The two measurements appear to be in disagreement, and so the magnificent thing that is scientific debate is now ensuing on this question.

The 2003 observations would suggest, based on the believed lifetimes of methane in the atmosphere of Mars of several hundred years, that Curiosity should have detected it a 6 ppb. Curiosity has ruled out concentrations greater than 1.3 ppb. So either the original observation is wrong, or the lifetime of methane is wrong, or the models of how it distributes in the atmosphere are wrong. Or all of the above. This article provides an excellent summary.

As to why we care so much about methane, it is because it is one signature of life. Both extant life, in the form of, for example, cows on Earth or microbes on Mars (on Earth it's actually made by microbes in the cows), or even extinct life in the form of buried organics producing natural gas as it does on the Earth. Methane is not however a definitive signature, since there are abiotic geological processes that produce methane as well. But it would have been of great interest in the search for life on Mars to find methane in the atmosphere, since even several hundred years is incredibly fast in geological terms, indicating a nearly constant production of methane to maintain anything detectable in the atmosphere.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.