Various news articles reporting the deployment of the heat and wind shield over the Insight seismometer describe it as measuring "vibrations that have an amplitude comparable to the size of an atom." or "tremors smaller than a hydrogen atom!" While amazing, this actually sounds pretty coarse by modern standards (compare LIGO which is sensitive to attometer scale distortions of its optical paths for instance). Does anyone actually have figures for the sensitivity?
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
4
asked Feb 5, 2019 at 9:08
-
3$\begingroup$ you try fitting LIGO on a lander $\endgroup$– user20636Feb 5, 2019 at 9:14
-
$\begingroup$ @JCRM tricky, I grant you, but on the other hand LIGO is roughly a billion times more sensitive to displacements of its mirrors (attometers vs nanometers) than Insight is to displacement of the ground underneath it. $\endgroup$– Steve LintonFeb 5, 2019 at 12:28
-
1$\begingroup$ The question is, is that level of precision necessary, or would an instrument that sensitive just generate enormous amounts of noise you have to filter out? They're trying to detect seismic events, not gravitational waves. $\endgroup$– HobbesFeb 5, 2019 at 12:39
-
3$\begingroup$ "When powered up on Earth, the SEIS seismometer is immediately disturbed by a level of background noise that makes it impossible to determine its real characteristics with any exactitude" -- contrary to the question it is very sensitive by "modern" seismology standards $\endgroup$– user20636Feb 5, 2019 at 14:14
Add a comment
|
1 Answer
$\begingroup$
$\endgroup$
Spacelfight 101's InSight Instrument Overview says:
SEIS is based on a six-axis hybrid instrument using two different sensor types: three Very Broad Band (VBB) seismic probes reside in a tetrahedron configuration within the vacuum sphere and three Short Period (SP) seismic probes are installed around it. These are supported by various temperature and pressure sensors plus a myriad of electronics, power supplies, feedback boards for the sensors and the MDE deployment system. SEIS has a mass of 11.5 Kilograms and is capable of measuring accelerations down to 10-9 m s-² Hz-½ over frequencies of 0.001 to 10 Hz and 5 x 10-8 m s-² Hz-½ from 0.01 to 100 Hz.
The SEIS sensor head weighs 8.5 Kilograms and is approximately 30 x 30 x 30 centimeters in size, featuring a hook on its upper face to interface with the InSight Instrument Deployment Arm to be lowered to the ground as part of the mission’s two-month commissioning phase.
Each of the VBBs is a leaf-spring inverted pendulum seismometer that employs a precisely defined test mass suspended on a pendulum and placed in motion by external inputs from the ground. Through highly precise Differential Capacitive Sensors (DCS) and electromagnetic feedback from the three VBBs, a three-axis representation of the ground motion can be reconstructed with nanometer precision.
So let's look at:
10-9 m s-² Hz-½ over frequencies of 0.001 to 10 Hz
and say you'd like to look at a range between 1 and 2 Hz. That's a bandwidth of 1 Hz, so the sensitivity would be 10-9 m/s2. Call the frequency $\omega = 2 \pi f = 6.28 \text{Hz}$ and walk backwards from acceleration to velocity to position:
$$acc = \cos(\omega t)$$ $$vel = \frac{1}{\omega} \sin(\omega t)$$ $$pos = -\frac{1}{\omega^2} \cos(\omega t)$$
That puts the sensitivity well below 1 Angstrom (10-10) but these are round numbers, and it also requires that the vibration continue for a while to separate it from noise.
The estimates that the amplitudes are of the size of an atom are well founded, but it will take significant signal processing, calibration, baselining, and characterization to really get there. All of the vibration isolation and environmental isolation systems will have to be in deployed and in good working order.
Source "SEIS Instrument Block Diagram – Image: ISAE/IPGP"
Source "Wind & Thermal Shield – Image: CNES/InSight Project"
You can read more about the requirements for the seismometers in The Noise Model of the SEIS Seismometer of the InSight Mission to Mars As you can see the noise and sensitivity analysis is fairly complicated and must take into account a number of contributions.
These limits are specs, we will have to wait a while to see how well the system is really performing on Mars.
Fig. 7 InSight performance requirements. The dashed lines apply only to the VBB vertical, while the solid lines apply to both horizontal and vertical components. Horizontal requirement envelope is reduced due to the tilt impact of several noise sources. In red, system requirements. In blue and green, instrument related requirements
The InSight accelerometers are made from micro-machined silicon MEMS structures and use similar technology to the MEMS accelerometers in personal electronics and games except they are much larger and highly refined. Since the z-axis (vertical) sustains more parallel force due to gravity than the other two axes, it is fabricated slightly differently, and so the noise specs are treated separately for vertical and horizontal.
From the question How was InSight's vertical seismometer (accelerometer) tested in Earth's stronger gravity?:
below: One of the microseismometer sensors, carved from a single piece of silicon 25mm square. Source
