3
$\begingroup$

Have any spacecraft (manned or unmanned) orbited the Earth in the same plane as the Sun?

(Please read the question carefully. It is not an orbit centered around the Sun, nor an equatorial orbit.)

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

This is an interesting question!

tl;dr: I don't know about artificially maintained orbits, but for uncontrolled orbits Earth's strong oblateness and the Moon's gravitational perturbations will not allow for an orbit parallel to the ecliptic to remain that way.

Near GEO:

We're looking for an Earth orbit with an inclination of 23 degrees, and a ascending node which either precesses naturally or is artificially precessed with a period of one year, so that the orbital plane approximately coincides with either the Earth's orbital plane or the official ecliptic (only a difference of 0.00005° at the moment).

I first though of geosynchronous junk and objects in a graveyard orbit. I know that without station-keeping those objects will drift in inclination away from geostationary, but will they eventually reach the plane of the ecliptic?

It seems not.

Wikipedia's Geostationary orbit; Orbital stability links to Anderson 2005, 66th International Astronautical Congress, paper IAC-15,A6,7,3,x27478, Operational Considerations of GEO Debris Synchronization Dynamics which explains that perturbations of both The Sun and The Moon (luni-solar perturbations) will cause the orbital plane to slowly oscillate between some limits in inclination, with the appropriate oscillation or monotonic advancement in the ascending node.

The plot below cuts off at 20 degrees but I think it's clear that orbits can peak at 23 degrees as well.

However, they don't stay there very long, and will turn around and head back to lower inclination before repeating the cycle.

The periods in both cases are around 53 years, according to the paper.

This is for orbits near GEO altitude and slightly elliptical but close to circular. If you are closer to Earth, or closer to the Moon, behavior will be dominated by other effects.

enter image description here

Fig. 2: Phase portraits illustrating admissible trajectories in inclination and RAAN phase space, governed by the doubly-averaged Equations (1)-(2) for inclination and RAAN variations driven by luni-solar perturbations at the GEO altitude.

Closer to Hill Sphere

If you get out close to the Earth's Hill sphere (around 1.5 million kilometers) the effects of the Sun could dominate that of the Moon and would certainly dominate Earth's oblateness, and you might be able to have a fairly stable Earth orbit that stays close to the ecliptic.

The Sun-Earth Lagrange points don't count

These are heliocentric orbits that are loosely tethered by Earth in a 1:1 resonance. If the Earth disappeared, the orbit would continue nicely around the Sun with only a small bump in eccentricity.

What Else (for uncontrolled orbits)?

Equations 1 and 2 in the linked paper Anderson 2005 can be applied to other orbits. One could try to scan a much larger range of orbit sizes to see if there is something that stays close to inclination of 23 degrees and where the nodes precess at $2\pi$/year.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ @DrSheldon switching back and forth between python and SE too often I guess, thanks! At some point I'll try to search for a spacecraft in on-line catalogs if someone else doesn't do it first. I think a final, conclusive answer has yet to be written... $\endgroup$ – uhoh Apr 26 at 4:34
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @DrSheldon comment cleanup? $\endgroup$ – uhoh Apr 26 at 13:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.