6
$\begingroup$

This answer taught me about J002E3, an object detected in Earth orbit in 2002 that is assumed to be the Saturn V IV-B stage from Apollo 12. It's trajectory through space is fascinating:

J002E3 animation

(source)

This announcement explains that the trajectory of the object has been propagated backwards in time to conclude it is most likely the IV-B stage from Apollo 12.

This made me wonder: is the trajectory of J002E3 available? Ideally I'd hope to see:

  1. historic measurement data from 1969
  2. actual observational data from 2002 to now
  3. simulated datapoints for in between (or: would an amateur like myself be able to simulate this from #1 and/or #2?)

(This answer explains that the trajectory looks funky in part by the choice of reference frame in the animation - I'd be really curious to see the trajectory in different frames.)

$\endgroup$
3
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ See the link to the article in Organic Marble's answer here space.stackexchange.com/questions/40005/…. There is some information (and trajectory plots) on Apollo 12 S-IVB maneuvers for slingshot over the moon. $\endgroup$ Nov 22, 2019 at 21:45
  • $\begingroup$ @LeoS Fascinating paper! I'll read it in more detail in the coming days. Should be part of an answer. $\endgroup$
    – Ludo
    Nov 22, 2019 at 21:52
  • $\begingroup$ I was hoping HORIZONS would tell me, but got the error No ephemeris for target "NEOCP J002E3" prior to A.D. 2003-FEB-28 23:58:55.8146 UT $\endgroup$
    – user7073
    Nov 25, 2019 at 15:35

1 Answer 1

5
$\begingroup$

Having researched this on and off since asking, my conclusion is: "not that much is known".

The object was discovered on Sept. 3, 2002 by amateur astronomer Bill Yeung. The Paul Chodas from Center for Near-Earth Object Studies (CNEOS) published a news item on Sept. 11, tentatively identifying it as the S-IVB stage of Apollo 12:

Analysis of J002E3’s pre-capture orbit about the Sun shows that the object was always inside the Earth’s orbit, and that it may have come within the Earth’s vicinity in the early 1970s or late 1960s. Many of the test cases in our analysis in fact passed through the L1 portal, back into Earth orbit (going backwards in time) during the early 1970s. In other words, this object was very likely orbiting the Earth during this period before escaping into the heliocentric orbit from which it was captured in 2002. It seems quite likely that this object is one of the Apollo Saturn S-IVB third stages which flew by the Moon during this era (Apollos 8 through 12). The brightness of J002E3 seems to match the expected brightness of an S-IVB stage. Further circumstantial evidence suggests that this object is in fact the Apollo 12 stage, which was left in a very distant Earth orbit after it passed by the Moon on November 18, 1969. This spent rocket body was last seen in an Earth orbit with a period of 43 days, not much different from J002E3’s current orbit.

I was unable to locate any publication on this analysis other than this news item.

A follow-up from Dr. Chodas, published on Sept. 20 explains that further observations have improved orbit reconstruction and concludes:

Additional observations have now confirmed that the object was indeed captured from a solar orbit earlier this year, and they have also made clear that it escaped the Earth-Moon system in March 1971. [...]
The timing of the object’s escape is consistent with our theory that this object is the Apollo 12 S-IVB third stage, which was left in a distant Earth orbit after it was launched on November 14, 1969 and passed the Moon four days later. We theorize that the spent rocket orbited the Earth chaotically for 15 months before finding the exit pathway through the L1 portal.

Again, no publication other than this news item.

A third update from Dr. Chodas from Oct. 10 concludes:

Looking into the past, we are still unable to connect the motion of J002E3 with the last know position of the Apollo 12 S-IVB. One reason is that the solar radiation pressure is not constant in time, but rather changes with its position around the sun; to precisely account for this effect we need to know the pole of rotation. Furthermore, if J002E3 is the Apollo 12 S-IVB then that stage spent more than a year in a highly chaotic orbit around the Earth. So far these two factors have combined to prevent us from predicting the position of J002E3 with sufficient precision to definitively link these two objects.

But again no publication associated as far as I can tell, also no further updates from CNEOS after this one.

In a 2012 publication (hat tip to Organic Marble), Daniel R. Adamo (who has a track record in state reconstruction, see e.g. this Q&A and references therein) reconstructed the trajectories of all the Apollo equipment that left for interplanetary space: "Earth Departure Trajectory Reconstruction of Apollo Program Components Undergoing Disposal in Interplanetary Space" (PDF). The section on Apollo 12's S-IVB reconstruction starts on page 40. The paper concludes, regarding J002E3:

Because the Apollo 12 S-IVB did not immediately depart Earth's vicinity due to a disposal targeting error, its fate is indeterminate with respect to this paper's scope. The trajectory reconstruction documented by this paper ends in a chaotic geocentric state with potential for collision with the Earth or Moon, along with the possibility of ejection into heliocentric orbit after a lunar encounter. This chaotic state is consistent with those observed in connection with object J002E3 circa late 2002, as documented in the report at http://neo.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news135.html

The CNEOS link is broken, but presumably pointed to the Sept. 20 update mentioned above (which was also captured by Spaceref.com) that also states that the orbit of J002E3 was chaotic and could not be definitely connected with the S-IVB trajectory.

The identification of J002E3 as a S-IVB stage was corroborated further by photometric analysis (reference, reference; both behind paywalls).

Concluding and answering the question:

  1. historic measurement data is presented in the paper by Daniel Adamo
  2. Somewhat recent trajectory data can be obtained from Horizons (search for J002E3; available time-span: March 1, 2003 to Jan 1, 2004)
  3. I was unable to locate any of the simulation data from the period from 1971 until 2003, nor was I able to find the raw observation data from September 2002 until J002E3's departure somewhere in 2003.
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.