6
$\begingroup$

Volatiles in polar craters on the Moon are great, but so far apparently it is unclear how much is there. Though I still have a lot of reading to do, so far I haven't found any information about what the Moon's bedrock might be like. Down there where the surface hasn't been churned by meteor strikes into dust, which has then been baked by solar radiation for eons, can we say whether or not the rock will have some of those volatiles bound into their minerals?

There was a case made in an answer to a recent question on Mars that nitrogen has to be on Mars. It is very common and the whole solar system was formed of the same basic stuff - that's the part that also applies to the Moon. That seems a solid argument, alright (though I'm looking for more sources to get the details, because I'd like to know more). But the Moon's history is so different. Is there good reason to hope that when we make it into a good lava tube, there will be nitrogen-containing minerals to be found? Some hydrogen minerals? Perhaps some carbon?

Do the interiors of rock samples from the moon really represent the composition of the crust, or have they been altered by the impact churning process? Since all of the rocky planets were formed from the same accretion disk, shouldn't a certain percentage of the elements missing from the Moon's surface be there, at some distance below the surface? If not, how were they stripped off?

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

What we know about lunar bedrock is mostly indirect.

The Apollo and Luna missions returned samples collected from the surface, and missions such as LRO use spectroscopy to analyze the lunar surface. The LRO Diviner instrument

is a multi-channel solar reflectance and infrared radiometer ... It has nine spectral channels which transmit different portions of the visible and infrared spectrum ...

Analysis of the lunar soil returned showed it to be a mixture (as might be expected) showing local variation with chunks from elsewhere.

According to JPL

One thing not apparent in the [Diviner] data is evidence for pristine lunar mantle material, which previous studies have suggested may be exposed at some places on the lunar surface. Even in the South Pole Aitken basin, also known as SPA, the largest, oldest, and deepest impact crater on the moon -- deep enough to have penetrated through the crust and into the mantle -- there is no evidence of mantle material.

Analysis of the fines in the returned samples showed capture of solar wind particles, yielding H, C and N in the 10-100 ppm range (pdf).

Overall analysis of the returned samples gives ground-truth context to the LRO data.

The crust of the Moon is made up of two main types of rock, anorthosite and basalt. Anorthosite is light in color because it is made up of a light-colored mineral called plagioclase feldspar. Basalt is dark in color because it contains the iron-bearing minerals pyroxene, olivine and ilmenite, along with volcanic glass. The iron present in these minerals tend to absorb light, making them appear dark. The light and dark areas on the Moon are composed of these rock types.

Plagioclase has a chemical composition of $\require{mhchem}\ce{NaAlSi3O8$ – $CaAl2Si2O8}$ as a repeating unit. Pyroxene is variable but (imprecisely speaking) contains either Si or Al and three Oxygen atoms. Olivine has a composition of $\ce{(Mg+2, Fe+2)2SiO4}$. Ilmenite has a composition of $\ce{FeTiO3}$.

Wikipedia has this summary of Lunar Prospector data Relative concentration of various elements on the lunar surface (in weight %)

and also this comparison of uplands, lowlands, and Earth: enter image description here

All of this just shows that there is plenty of Oxygen and other useful minerals available, but precious little of other volatiles.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

There are some lunar phenomena that suggest volatile deposits beneath the lunar crust. Spudis believes LTPs might be from outgassing of such deposits. If such outgassings do occur, most of would spread across the moon's surface and eventually escape from the moon's gravity well. But perhaps some of these volatiles would find their way to the lunar cold traps.

Francis McCubbins re-analyzed lunar samples and found lunar water may be more common than was earlier thought. However his samples were still very dry -- 64 to 5 parts per billion. Dr. Boyce has argued that the lunar magma may be drier than what McCubbins estimated.

The solar wind might be the source of some lunar water. The protons from the sun are hydrogen ions. Most of the lunar crust is oxygen compounds, for example silica and alumina. The hydrogen ions from the solar wind might interact with these oxygen compounds to make water. Some of these water molecules might find their way to the lunar cold traps.

If there are substantial volatiles at the lunar poles, I would bet they come from asteroid and comet impacts on the lunar surface. Some of the volatiles released at impact would spread across the lunar surface, most eventually escaping the moon. But some fraction of the impact volatiles might find their way to the cold traps and remain there when the 30 to 40 k temperatures turn them to ice.

In summary, the origin of the Moon's polar volatiles remains an open question.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ The lunar transient phenomena link is pretty interesting, i wasn't aware of those. The two other articles linked to focus on water, and i don't know to what degree that is also a comment on hydrogen in general. What i'm really wondering about is whether much can be said about what the Moon is made of, below the point where its composition has been heavily altered by impacts and solar wind. Do the interiors of Apollo rock samples represent an accurate picture of that? $\endgroup$ – kim holder Mar 1 '15 at 22:13
  • $\begingroup$ Actually, now that i read the first link properly, the off-gassing events do sound pretty suggestive that there are volatiles at 'some depth'. Perhaps not at all a convenient depth. $\endgroup$ – kim holder Mar 1 '15 at 22:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.