8
$\begingroup$

We know from Flying on dense atmosphere planets & moons that many bodies in our solar system have sufficient atmosphere for at least the concept of flying to be considered.

What about the beauty of a rainbow, the sun reflecting through drops of water hanging in the air, the magical way they move as you do. Would moving to another planet or moon in our solar system mean the end of seeing rainbows?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Reopened, we agreed in our Space Exploration Meta 3 weeks after closing this question (Aug 2 '13) that planetary science is on-topic and added it to our scope. Having this question closed, while we have similar newer question regarding atmospheric physics of non-terrestrial planets open and never disputed as off-topic, seemed wrong. If you notice other, older planetary science questions closed as off-topic with closing date from before Aug 23 '13, please nominate them for reopening (link under the question) and/or flag for moderator's attention. Thanks! $\endgroup$ – TildalWave May 18 '14 at 15:16
13
$\begingroup$

There is a possibility of rainbows appearing naturally on other celestial bodies that have sufficient water vapor or a large number of water droplets in their atmospheres, or indeed gases or droplets of other molecules that are capable of acting upon the light from the Sun (or other sources) as tiny prisms and refract it to its visible components (different wavelengths). Another possibility is also mineral dust scattered in the atmosphere, or indeed in planetary rings:

   Refraction of transparent minerals

                   Scatter plot of refraction of various transparent minerals and their density (source: physics.info)

Problem is, we don't really know which celestial bodies in our Solar system might that be. Mars has possibly too thin atmosphere and not enough water vapor (210 ppm) for any such effect to be really noticeable, and we don't know enough about atmospheric conditions of other planets and their moons.

But there are other possibilities. For example Titan, one of Saturn's moons, has liquid methane (refraction index of 1.29):

       Titan's Many Layers

       Titan's layers of atmosphere in the UV + visible spectrum, image from the Cassini–Huygens spacecraft (source: Wikipedia)

Even stronger case for possible rainbow effect forming on the surface of Titan comes from Cassini and Huygens observations, indicating that Titan might have a pretty complex weather system and precipitation in the form of liquid methane rain:

Conditions in Titan's troposphere are near the triple point of methane, the second most abundant component of its atmosphere. Our understanding of Titan's lower atmosphere has shifted considerably in the past decade. Ground-based observations, Hubble Space Telescope images, and data returned from the Cassini and Huygens spacecraft show that Titan's troposphere hosts a methane-based meteorology in direct analogy to the water-based meteorology of Earth. What once was thought to be a quiescent place, lacking in clouds or localized weather and changing only subtly on long seasonal timescales, is now understood to be a dynamic system with significant weather events regularly occurring against the backdrop of dramatic seasonal changes. Although the observational record of Titan's weather covers only a third of its 30-year seasonal cycle, Titan's atmospheric processes appear to be more closely analogous to those of Earth than to those of any other object in our solar system.

(Source: Titan's Methane Weather, Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Lowell Observatory, May 2012)


Update: In July 2011 a glory, a rainbow-like feature has been observed for the first time on another planet by ESA's Venus Express probe:

The atmosphere of Venus is thought to contain droplets rich in sulphuric acid. By imaging the clouds with the Sun directly behind the Venus Express spacecraft, scientists hoped to spot a glory in order to determine important characteristics of the cloud droplets.

They were successful. The glory in the images here was seen at the Venus cloud tops, 70 km above the planet’s surface, on 24 July 2011. It is 1200 km wide as seen from the spacecraft, 6000 km away.

   enter image description here

   This simulated view shows how a glory would appear on Venus (left) versus Earth (right). (Source: Nature.com)

It's beyond me why this took nearly 3 years to make its public debut in April 2014, but here we have it, a rainbow on another celestial body than Earth:

                              enter image description here

        An optical effect called a glory seen by the Venus Express probe from an altitude of 6,000 kilometres. The false-colour image
        is composed of images at ultraviolet, visible, and near-infrared wavelengths taken ten seconds apart, so that they do not
        overlap perfectly. (Caption credit: Nature.com, Image source: ESA)

Discovery of this glory isn't merely a pretty sight, but gives Cytherean atmospheric physicists clues about its composition, among other things. For example, New Scientist article, referencing Icarus, DOI: 10.1016/j.icarus.2014.01.030 (Markiewicz et al.), puts it like this:

The team found that sulphuric acid droplets alone cannot explain the glory, but droplets coated with elemental sulphur or mixed in with ferric chloride fit the data well.

"This could be the so-called unknown absorber that people had been trying to identify for years," Markiewicz says. "We cannot say for sure, but we can say that this is one more piece of the puzzle for the whole thing."

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Sufficient water vapor does not produce rainbows, water droplets are necessary. No droplets, no rainbow possible. $\endgroup$ – Uwe Sep 14 at 18:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.