69
votes
Accepted
Why doesn’t NASA build its rockets using graphene?
The Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of graphene is at 2 or 3 as far as I can tell. And that is TRL as related to making very tiny stuff.
Anything used to build a structure for aircraft or spacecraft ...
- 3,042
67
votes
Why can't they just drop a solar winch down from a shuttle and have planes fly up and clip things on?
Because space isn't about going high; it's about going fast! For example, in a 400 km orbit (like ISS) you need a speed of about 27,500 km/h or 7.66 km per second.
So if you would extend a ...
- 12.5k
66
votes
Would it be practical to catch a rocket's exhaust to reuse it as fuel?
Like any perpetual motion machine, it won't work. In this case, there are two major reasons.
First, your "send back fuel" arrow is pushing mass forward; every action has an equal and ...
- 167k
54
votes
Accepted
Could a space colony 1g from the sun work?
Interesting but no, it wouldn't work for the same reason that astronauts in the International Space Station, other space stations, or orbiting shuttles or capsules do not "feel" gravity with respect ...
- 149k
52
votes
Are there any greater risks of traveling significantly faster to another planet?
The biggest risk on a flight to Mars is cumulative exposure to radiation, so a 1-2 month flight would actually be much healthier for a crew than a 7-8 month flight. I don't know of any risks that ...
- 167k
51
votes
Accepted
Why isn't SpaceX constructing the Super Heavy launch mount on top of the water?
Salt does all sorts of unpleasant things to just about every building material humans use. Hot salt spray, such as you'd get from a rocket launch, is even worse: spraying something with hot saltwater ...
- 14.6k
47
votes
Accepted
Why aren't air breathing engines used as small first stages?
Take a look at the SABRE engine. The goal is to achieve single stage runway liftoff/land to/from orbit with a hybrid engine capable of breathing air at low altitude but switching to stored oxidizer ...
- 17.4k
44
votes
Why aren't air breathing engines used as small first stages?
Systems that do this exist and more are being introduced. It's just that they hide their appearance and look somewhat different to what would be expected from what you describe.
Orbital Sciences ...
- 869
42
votes
Why doesn’t NASA build its rockets using graphene?
Besides the fact BradV pointed out that we don't have the technology to do this yet, the fact is that graphene on a macroscopic scale would not perform as well as the numbers you cited suggest. All ...
- 10.2k
41
votes
Accepted
Wouldn't it make sense to use parachutes for aborting test flights rather than destroying the whole rocket?
The ability to successfully deploy a parachute still requires some level of stability or control, it's simply not an option for a badly out-of-control rocket. In cases where something goes wrong, the ...
- 3,687
38
votes
Accepted
Exactly why does Starship need to be this big for interplanetary travel?
A lot of launch costs are independent of rocket size. It's no cheaper to clear the flight path for a smaller rocket, for example. It also takes a lot longer to do 10 launches instead of one large ...
- 10.7k
37
votes
Accepted
Would a grinding machine be a simple and workable propulsion system for an interplanetary spacecraft?
The main engineering challenge in implementing your proposal is that in order to be competitive with a chemical rocket engine, the grinding wheel must rotate at an extremely high velocity. A typical ...
- 486
37
votes
Accepted
Could an electromagnet be used to raise the apogee of a satellite orbiting Earth?
You might like to take a look at Electromagnetic Tethers. A spacecraft moving through a magnetic field (such as the Earth's) can deploy a long, trailing wire and run a current through it. This will ...
- 700
37
votes
Accepted
Orbital Supercomputer for Martian and Outer Planet Computing
They act as a massive supercomputer
I think you massively underestimate how massive a massive supercomputer is, and most importantly, how massive both the power requirements and the cooling ...
- 18k
33
votes
Would a duct tape spacesuit be practical?
If the suit would be useful, it has to be inflated. Which is definitively not how it looks like in images. If you could manage duct tape to hold the inner pressure for a moment without rupturing and/...
- 1,831
31
votes
What are the biggest challenges for high altitude rail-gun launch systems?
What you're describing is (more or less) the StarTram "gen 1" design.
The reference design has:
40 tonne unmanned cargo projectile, 25 tonnes of payload, ~2 m wide, ~13 m long.
A 130 km maglev ...
- 8,001
30
votes
Could sheets of stacked graphene be used as part of a heat shield, since its melting point is 3000k to 5000 K
For a non ablative heat shield you need a material with a very high melting point and a very low thermal conductivity. It should not burn in hot air.
Unfortunately graphene seems to have a high ...
- 48.8k
28
votes
Accepted
Rocket flywheel instead of battery/generator (crazy idea)?
A flywheel is so efficient because it is big and heavy, both of which you don't want to add to a spacecraft. As for spinning an existing component, the only parts of a rocket that really have any ...
- 18k
27
votes
If someone built a vacuum tunnel through the atmosphere, could you have an orbit with a sea level perigee?
No, unless your structure is located directly on the equator and your satellite follows a perfectly circular orbit, atmospheric "orbits" aren't possible, even in a vacuum tunnel.
Because the ...
- 18k
27
votes
Why is it not concerning from a cost perspective to have so many engines on Starship?
Because with current technology, the greatest part of expense in building a rocket motor is not the individual construction, but the research needed in the design of it.
And it is simpler, easier and ...
26
votes
Accepted
Why is it not concerning from a cost perspective to have so many engines on Starship?
Economy of scale, strictly. SpaceX focuses heavily on streamlining and automation of production of these engines. High up-front cost, but low unit cost per engine once the process is perfected.
The ...
- 54.9k
25
votes
Accepted
What would be necessary in order for us to achieve a single stage to orbit, reusable rocket?
I am referring to rockets capable of taking supplies and humans to other planets.
For an interplanetary single-stage rocket with tens to hundreds of tons of payload capability, no existing propulsion ...
- 167k
23
votes
Accepted
Could one actually make a grain silo rocket?
Since the term "grain" is already in use in the solid rocket context, I'm favoring the term "cereal".
Cereals contain about 66–76% carbohydrates -- mostly starch (55–70%) plus some ...
- 167k
22
votes
What would be necessary in order for us to achieve a single stage to orbit, reusable rocket?
Rockets are basically devices which exploit Newton's Third Law, for every force there is an equal and opposite force. By throwing mass out the back as fast as possible this imparts an equal force that ...
- 7,996
22
votes
Would a higher air pressure on the ISS or elsewhere make it easier to "swim" in microgravity?
Would a higher air pressure on the ISS or elsewhere make it easier to “swim” in microgravity?
Yes!
But what's really important is the density, so instead of pressuring "normal air" you can ...
- 149k
21
votes
Accepted
Can a rocket refuel on Mars from water?
It absolutely could! First of all, water can be split in to hydrogen and oxygen, which can be enough to launch a rocket. Hydrogen requires a very low temperature, and the rocket engine doesn't have as ...
- 121k
21
votes
What are the biggest challenges for high altitude rail-gun launch systems?
Many novel launch schemes need some amount of help from rockets. What
kills a lot of them is doing a tradeoff study of just enlarging the rocket
part and getting rid of the non-rocket part. ...
21
votes
Accepted
Terraforming Mars using a combination of aerogel and GM microbes?
The underlying aerogel scheme seems to have some serious fundamental flaws:
Aerogel is extremely expensive, and you need enough to cover a significant portion of a planet.
Aerogel is extremely ...
- 10.7k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible