12
$\begingroup$

As we all know Jupiter is a gaseous planet so what would happen if an Earth-sized object happened to encounter Jupiter?

  1. Would Jupiter engulf the object and make it stay at Jupiter's core?
  2. Would the object get fragmented as when two solid objects hit each other?

or what would be the effect?

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Similar question on Physics.SE: physics.stackexchange.com/questions/145237 $\endgroup$ – Kyle Kanos Jul 21 '15 at 17:40
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Also this is probably a little off-topic, since it's not related to exploration. It might be worth migrating to Physics.SE, but you would need to edit your question and describe how the "Earth-sized body" in your question and the "(large) solid planet" in the other are different enough to make the two questions distinct. $\endgroup$ – Panzercrisis Jul 21 '15 at 21:07
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ At planetary and larger scales, all materials act like fluids (that's why they're all spherical). So both Jupiter and the earth-like object would deform according to the mutually-influenced changes in their gravity wells, until they actually made contact... $\endgroup$ – RBarryYoung Jul 21 '15 at 21:42
  • $\begingroup$ First, we don't think that Jupiter is gaseous through and through - it might have a rocky core, and there's some suggestions that it might have a metallic hydrogen core. Second, gases still colide. Remember how meteors and satellites burn up in atmosphere during reentry? At high enough speed and atmospheric density, you're going to get something quite close to a solid collision - and Jupiter has a dense "atmosphere" indeed. So yes, fragmentation will happen. Some of the fragments might eventually sink to the core, and some might be thrown into orbit (or out of it even). $\endgroup$ – Luaan Jul 22 '15 at 7:32
  • $\begingroup$ This question is off-topic and should be migrated to Physics. $\endgroup$ – curiousdannii Jul 29 '15 at 9:29
7
$\begingroup$

I like the answers, but I'm going to give a brief intuitive answer in addition.

Would Jupiter engulf the object and make it stay at Jupiter's core?

reading the other question, which I'm sure you read as well, here I think the safe answer is yes, Earth would be engulfed in Jupiter, though the impact spash would be impressive. I wouldn't want to guess as to exactly what would happen, but it would be, impressive.

Now if it was more of a glancing blow, large chunks of the Earth like planet could pass through and escape, but Jupiter is 10 times the diameter of Earth and quite solid with very high pressure inside. It's hard to see anything short of a Neutron Star passing through that with relative ease. The Jupiter mass rocky planet scenario wouldn't be so much a pass through as a blow up.

As pointed out, the Earth like planet simply approaching Jupiter would begin to break apart.

Would the object get fragmented as when two solid objects hit each other?

Fragmentation is slowed by gravity. When Earth was hit by Theia - a mars sized planet, at, not sure the velocity but lets say 15-25 KM per second, as it was likely a Trojan orbit, similar to Earth's orbit so the velocity was largely in line, and mostly driven by Earth's and Theia's combined gravitational pull towards each other. If you imagine 2 rocks smashing into each other at 20 times the speed of a bullet, the rocks would pulverize each other, and that's basically what happened with Earth and Theia, you got pulverized planets, a whole lot of heat and the Earth was sent a spinning, but you don't always get debris everywhere cause gravity is a big factor and that can keep a planet together.

This is an Earth-Theia simulation, a glancing blow (a direct hit and more mass would likely have been lost).

enter image description here

And this is probobly a pretty good estimate for an Earth like planet hitting Jupiter. Most of the debris would fall back to jupiter, a share, would have a good chance of forming either a ring (inside the Roche limit) or a moon (outside Jupiter's Roche limit) and a fair bit of matter would fly off and escape Jupiter's gravity given an impact that large. But as a general rule, the larger the planet being hit, the harder it is to blow material into space. Still, a collision this big, I think it would happen.

or what would be the effect?

The Earth, being 1/300th the mass of Jupiter, the crash would change Jupiter's orbit slightly but measurably, by a few tens of MPH and perhaps having a similar smallish effect on it's rotational velocity.

The collision could also be hot enough to make Jupiter glow, probobly enough to be clearly visible to the naked eye. How much - too hard for me to say, but perhaps it would look like a tiny sun but far outshining Venus, perhaps even, approaching the brightness of the full moon for a few hours. The glow might also change with Jupiter's rotation, which takes 10 hours, you could see it grow brighter and dimmer over a 10 hour period for a few days. It would be quite the show through a telescope, assuming it wouldn't be too bright, but you could watch the debris cloud take shape over several hours and perhaps form into a new moon in a few days.

Finally, another effect would likely be debris, even if it's mostly hydrogen, scattered around the solar system. If Jupiter was rocky, it would be far worse for us, as you'd likely get some enormous meteor showers in a few years and perhaps a few major meteor impacts (for example, if this happened on Mars, it would be quite bad for us), but Jupiter's more gaseous composition, I don't think that would be the case. The new dust clouds would be more curiosities than things to worry about.

It's worth pointing out that an earth sized object simply passing through the solar system could be quite problematic, not affecting the planets too much, but stirring up Kuiper belt objects or asteroids in the asteroid belt and sending them every which way, perhaps a few towards Earth - not a good situation for us, but that kind of new object passing through happens very rarely.

$\endgroup$
15
$\begingroup$

If you saw the video of the Shoemaker-Levy collision you will see that although that was a collection of smaller objects, there is very much a collision, rather than a gas engulfing a solid.

Once the object gets within Jupiter's Roche limit it will be torn to pieces, so you will have a hail of objects falling in and burning up through the atmosphere.

The Roche limit (pronounced /ʁoʃ/ in IPA, similar to the sound of rosh), sometimes referred to as the Roche radius, is the distance within which a celestial body, held together only by its own gravity, will disintegrate due to a second celestial body's tidal forces exceeding the first body's gravitational self-attraction.

From Roche limit - Wikipedia

This distance for Earth would be about 16.35 Earth radii, or 104,200 km.

Large enough chunks may survive and 'float' at a depth that matches their density - this may not be at the core...

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ thanks for answering,what would happen if a large body equal to or greater than jupiter hits? $\endgroup$ – SpringLearner Jul 21 '15 at 11:52
  • $\begingroup$ That would be a big chunk of rock! $\endgroup$ – Rory Alsop Jul 21 '15 at 11:54
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ Would the breakup of an object within the Roche limit be immediate? I had the impression it was a long-timescale thing. $\endgroup$ – Russell Borogove Jul 21 '15 at 14:08
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @RussellBorogove I imagine that would depend on the angle and velocity of the Earth-sized body's approach. $\endgroup$ – called2voyage Jul 21 '15 at 14:12
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ @RussellBorogove The Roche limit is concerned only with the gravitational forces. In reality, you'd need to get much closer to be ripped apart, since Earth also sticks together thanks to electromagnetism. The first things lost would be those that only stick thanks to gravity - the atmosphere, loose soil, surface water... That can give you an impression of a gradual process - different materials are bound together with different forces, so as the tidal force increases, more and more of the material would be unbound (and slowly scattered). $\endgroup$ – Luaan Jul 22 '15 at 7:26
8
$\begingroup$

Depending on what you mean by encounter:

Close to Jupiter's Gravity Influence

If the planet comes into Jupiter's gravity influence the trajectory will be changed significantly. If it no longer has the necessary velocity to escape then it may be captured and become a new moon of Jupiter. On a smaller scale, this is what likely happened around Mars with Phobos and Deimos.

If the Earth-sized planet would encounter Jupiter within it's Roche Limit it would be torn apart. It's possible then that the torn apart debris would settle into a more vibrant ring system than Jupiter's current. This is possibly what happened to one of Saturn's moons to form it's current ring system.

Direct Impact Into Jupiter

If the Earth-sized planet is to directly hit Jupiter, it would follow the same as above to begin; the planet would reach an altitude below the Roche Limit and be broken into smaller pieces. These pieces would be further broken down as the rubble moved closer, until the final pieces impacted with Jupiter. The pressure of the pieces moving through the Jovian atmosphere would likely cause a heatup and explosion, similar to objects entering Earth's atmosphere. The majority, if not the entirety of the objects would be vaporized as a result.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.